Studying Hitler’s Daughter in High School English: Why This Story Still Matters
- Anna @ Tea4Teacher
- Jan 23
- 4 min read
For students in Years 7–9, studying Hitler’s Daughter in High School English offers a powerful blend of accessibility, historical context, and ethical inquiry. Its framing, speculative premise, and emotional impact make it an ideal text for developing critical thinking, empathy, and discussion skills in the English classroom.
Jackie French’s Hitler’s Daughter is one of the most thought-provoking novels studied in lower high school English. Though slim in length, it asks some of the biggest questions students will encounter in literature: Are people born evil, or shaped by their choices? How responsible are individuals for the actions of others? And what does it mean to stand by while harm is done?
A Clear and Engaging Plot Summary
The novel is structured as a story within a story, which immediately captures student interest. Each day while waiting for the school bus, a small group of children listen as Anna tells them a story about a girl named Heidi who may be Adolf Hitler’s daughter.
Heidi grows up in isolation, raised by foster parents in a small village. She is an ordinary child who enjoys learning, playing, and dreaming about the world beyond her home.
Gradually, however, she becomes aware that her father is Adolf Hitler, a man responsible for immense suffering and destruction. As Heidi learns more about his actions, she struggles with shame, fear, and confusion about her own identity.
Heidi’s life becomes increasingly restricted as she is hidden away to protect the regime’s image. Despite her circumstances, she begins to question the ideology surrounding her and makes small but significant choices to resist cruelty. Ultimately, her story is one of moral awakening rather than power or heroism.
At the end of the novel, Anna reveals that Heidi never existed. The story was a thought experiment designed to make the listeners, and the reader, consider how ordinary people are implicated in systems of harm. This revelation reframes the entire narrative and prompts students to reflect on responsibility, complicity, and choice.
Why the Story Works for Younger Secondary Students
One of the greatest strengths of Hitler’s Daughter is its accessibility. The language is clear, the chapters are short, and the narrative is tightly focused. This makes it manageable for lower high school students, including reluctant readers and EAL learners.
Despite its simplicity, the novel does not talk down to students. Instead, it trusts them with complex ideas presented in a way they can engage with. The speculative premise allows students to approach the topic of Nazism without being overwhelmed by graphic detail, while still grappling with its moral weight.
The bus-stop framing device also mirrors the way young people share stories and ideas, making the novel feel conversational rather than distant or academic.
Exploring Big Ethical Questions Safely
Hitler’s Daughter is particularly effective for introducing ethical discussion in the English classroom. Rather than focusing solely on historical facts, the novel centres on moral choice. Students are encouraged to consider whether individuals are responsible for the actions of those they are connected to, and how silence or inaction can contribute to harm.
Heidi’s situation invites students to ask uncomfortable but important questions. Would they act differently in her place? How much power does one person really have within an unjust system? These discussions help students practise respectful disagreement and perspective-taking, skills that are essential far beyond English lessons.
Because the story is fictional, students can explore these ideas at a safe distance, reducing defensiveness while still engaging deeply.
Key Themes and Ideas
One of the central themes of the novel is responsibility. The revelation that “everyone knew” about Hitler’s actions but did nothing forces students to confront the danger of bystanders. This theme connects powerfully to modern contexts, including bullying, discrimination, and social justice issues.
Identity is another key theme. Heidi struggles with the idea that her father’s actions define her. This resonates with young adolescents who are beginning to form their own identities and question how much control they have over how they are seen.
The novel also explores the power of stories themselves. Anna’s storytelling frames the novel as an act of inquiry rather than entertainment, reinforcing the idea that stories help us think through difficult questions.
Classroom Relevance and Teaching Opportunities
From a teaching perspective, Hitler’s Daughter offers rich opportunities for both analytical and creative tasks. Students can analyse character, theme, and narrative structure, or respond through diary entries, alternative endings, or ethical reflections.
The text works particularly well alongside history units on World War II, allowing for cross-curricular connections. It also supports discussions about propaganda, obedience, and moral courage, linking past events to contemporary issues.
Because the novel is short, it allows time for revisiting key passages, modelling analytical writing, and practising paragraph structure without rushing.
Why Hitler’s Daughter Endures
Hitler’s Daughter endures because it treats young readers with respect. It does not offer easy answers or heroic solutions. Instead, it asks students to think carefully about choice, responsibility, and humanity.
In lower high school English classrooms, it opens the door to deep thinking while remaining accessible and engaging. Few texts manage to be both confronting and appropriate for young readers. Jackie French’s novel does exactly that, making it a powerful and enduring choice for study.
_____________________________________________________________________________
*Check out the great high school English resources available in the Tea4Teacher store!
_____________________________________________________________________________
Comments